Newer
Older
Presentations / Kstmumu / 09_04_2015_Mom_LL_discrepancy / Systematics.tex
@mchrzasz mchrzasz on 6 May 2015 7 KB big commit of everything
  1. \documentclass[xcolor=svgnames]{beamer}
  2. \usepackage[utf8]{inputenc}
  3. \usepackage[english]{babel}
  4. \usepackage{polski}
  5. %\usepackage{amssymb,amsmath}
  6. %\usepackage[latin1]{inputenc}
  7. %\usepackage{amsmath}
  8. %\newcommand\abs[1]{\left|#1\right|}
  9. \usepackage{amsmath}
  10. \newcommand\abs[1]{\left|#1\right|}
  11. \usepackage{hepnicenames}
  12. \usepackage{hepunits}
  13. \usepackage{color}
  14.  
  15.  
  16.  
  17. %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%5
  18. \definecolor{mygreen}{cmyk}{0.82,0.11,1,0.25}
  19.  
  20.  
  21. \usetheme{Sybila}
  22.  
  23. \title[Cross checks]{Cross checks}
  24. \author{Marcin Chrz\k{a}szcz$^{1}$, Nicola Serra$^{1}$}
  25. \institute{$^1$~University of Zurich}
  26. \date{\today}
  27.  
  28. \begin{document}
  29. % --------------------------- SLIDE --------------------------------------------
  30. \frame[plain]{\titlepage}
  31. \author{Marcin Chrz\k{a}szcz{~}}
  32. \institute{(UZH)}
  33. % ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  34. % --------------------------- SLIDE --------------------------------------------
  35. \section{Background studies}
  36. \begin{frame}\frametitle{Comparison MoM with LL fit}
  37. \begin{columns}
  38. \begin{column}{2.5in}
  39. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs/Fl.pdf}\\
  40. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs/S3.pdf}
  41. \end{column}
  42. \begin{column}{2.5in}
  43. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs/Fs.pdf}\\
  44. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs/S4.pdf}
  45. \end{column}
  46. \end{columns}
  47. \end{frame}
  48.  
  49. \begin{frame}\frametitle{Comparison MoM with LL fit}
  50. \begin{columns}
  51. \begin{column}{2.5in}
  52. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs/S5.pdf}\\
  53. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs/S6.pdf}
  54. \end{column}
  55. \begin{column}{2.5in}
  56. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs/S7.pdf}\\
  57. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs/S8.pdf}
  58. \end{column}
  59. \end{columns}
  60. \end{frame}
  61.  
  62.  
  63.  
  64. \begin{frame}\frametitle{Expected differences, MoM vs fit}
  65. \begin{itemize}
  66. \item We checked this already but as number of sigma is a bit to large for me.
  67. \item Let me put once again all the numbers I have in once place.
  68. \end{itemize}
  69.  
  70. \only<1>{
  71. \begin{itemize}
  72. \item Here Signal only, WITH acceptance.
  73. \end{itemize}
  74.  
  75.  
  76.  
  77. \begin{tiny}
  78. \begin{tabular}{ |c |c | c | c| c| c| c| c|c|}
  79. \hline
  80. {~} & \multicolumn{8}{|c|}{ absolute expected difference at $68\%$ CL} \\ \hline
  81. $q^2 [GeV^2 /c^4]$ & $F_l$ & $S_3$ & $S_4$ & $S_5$ & $S_6$ & $S_7$ & $S_8$ & $S_9$ \\ \hline
  82. $0.1 - 0.98$ & $0.035$ & $0.021$ & $0.044$ & $0.028$ & $0.073$ & $0.025$ & $0.038$ & $0.062$ \\ \hline
  83. $1.1 - 2.5$ & $0.062$ & $0.065$ & $0.082$ & $0.061$ & $0.073$ & $0.065$ & $0.084$ & $0.062$ \\ \hline
  84. $2.5 - 4.0$ & $0.062$ & $0.067$ & $0.085$ & $0.077$ & $0.065$ & $0.072$ & $0.080$ & $0.042$ \\ \hline
  85. $4.0 - 6.0$ & $0.043$ & $0.044$ & $0.059$ & $0.056$ & $0.027$ & $0.052$ & $0.054$ & $0.038$ \\ \hline
  86. $6.0 - 8.0$ & $0.038$ & $0.042$ & $0.056$ & $0.053$ & $0.028$ & $0.045$ & $0.051$ & $0.027$ \\ \hline
  87. $15.0 - 17.0$ & $0.027$ & $0.044$ & $0.051$ & $0.042$ & $0.032$ & $0.034$ & $0.045$ & $0.034$ \\ \hline
  88. $17.0 - 19.0$ & $0.034$ & $0.059$ & $0.066$ & $0.055$ & $0.044$ & $0.043$ & $0.056$ & $0.049$ \\ \hline
  89. \end{tabular}
  90. \end{tiny}
  91. }
  92.  
  93.  
  94. \end{frame}
  95.  
  96.  
  97. \begin{frame}\frametitle{Pull distribution}
  98. \begin{itemize}
  99. \item Take the observed difference($S_x^{MoM}-S_x^{Fit}$) and divide by the expected difference from table above.
  100. \end{itemize}
  101.  
  102. \includegraphics[width=0.6\textwidth]{obs/pull.pdf}
  103.  
  104. \begin{itemize}
  105. \item Important note: The fit I do is weighted, but the pull was obtained using Christoph fit which is unweighed, aka we are comparing apples to oranges here.
  106. \item Now repeat the exercise with my own fit weighted fit.
  107. \end{itemize}
  108. \end{frame}
  109.  
  110.  
  111. \begin{frame}\frametitle{Comparison MoM with LL fit}
  112. \begin{columns}
  113. \begin{column}{2.5in}
  114. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs2/Fl.pdf}\\
  115. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs2/S3.pdf}
  116. \end{column}
  117. \begin{column}{2.5in}
  118. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs2/Fs.pdf}\\
  119. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs2/S4.pdf}
  120. \end{column}
  121. \end{columns}
  122. \end{frame}
  123.  
  124. \begin{frame}\frametitle{Comparison MoM with LL fit}
  125. \begin{columns}
  126. \begin{column}{2.5in}
  127. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs2/S5.pdf}\\
  128. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs2/S6.pdf}
  129. \end{column}
  130. \begin{column}{2.5in}
  131. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs2/S7.pdf}\\
  132. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs2/S8.pdf}
  133. \end{column}
  134. \end{columns}
  135. \end{frame}
  136.  
  137. \begin{frame}\frametitle{Pull distribution}
  138. \begin{itemize}
  139. \item Take the observed difference($S_x^{MoM}-S_x^{Fit}$) and divide by the expected difference from table above.
  140. \end{itemize}
  141.  
  142. \includegraphics[width=0.6\textwidth]{obs2/pull.pdf}
  143.  
  144. \begin{itemize}
  145. \item Now oranges to oranges.
  146. \end{itemize}
  147. \end{frame}
  148.  
  149.  
  150.  
  151.  
  152.  
  153.  
  154. \begin{frame}%\frametitle{~}
  155.  
  156. \begin{Huge}
  157.  
  158. \center{BACKUP}
  159.  
  160. \end{Huge}
  161. \end{frame}
  162.  
  163.  
  164.  
  165.  
  166. \begin{frame}\frametitle{Comparison MoM with LL fit}
  167. \begin{columns}
  168. \begin{column}{2.5in}
  169. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs/S5_P.pdf}
  170. \end{column}
  171. \begin{column}{2.5in}
  172. \includegraphics[width=0.9\textwidth]{obs/S9.pdf}\\
  173.  
  174. \end{column}
  175. \end{columns}
  176. \begin{itemize}
  177. \item My personal opinion: Despite what is expected the left plot scares the hell out of me!
  178. \end{itemize}
  179.  
  180. \end{frame}
  181.  
  182.  
  183. \begin{frame}\frametitle{Expected differences, MoM vs fit}
  184. \begin{itemize}
  185. \item We checked this already but as number of sigma is a bit to large for me.
  186. \item Let me put once again all the numbers I have in once place.
  187. \end{itemize}
  188.  
  189.  
  190. \only<1>{
  191. \begin{itemize}
  192. \item Here Signal only, no acceptance.
  193. \end{itemize}
  194.  
  195.  
  196.  
  197. \begin{tiny}
  198. \begin{tabular}{ |c |c | c | c| c| c| c| c|c|}
  199. \hline
  200. {~} & \multicolumn{8}{|c|}{ absolute expected difference at $68\%$ CL} \\ \hline
  201. $q^2 [GeV^2 /c^4]$ & $F_l$ & $S_3$ & $S_4$ & $S_5$ & $S_6$ & $S_7$ & $S_8$ & $S_9$ \\ \hline
  202. $0.1 - 0.98$ & $0.015$ & $0.014$ & $0.023$ & $0.014$ & $0.013$ & $0.012$ & $0.019$ & $0.021$ \\ \hline
  203. $1.1 - 2.5$ & $0.021$ & $0.025$ & $0.026$ & $0.024$ & $0.015$ & $0.024$ & $0.025$ & $0.020$ \\ \hline
  204. $2.5 - 4.0$ & $0.020$ & $0.022$ & $0.024$ & $0.025$ & $0.013$ & $0.023$ & $0.024$ & $0.016$ \\ \hline
  205. $4.0 - 6.0$ & $0.016$ & $0.017$ & $0.021$ & $0.020$ & $0.010$ & $0.019$ & $0.019$ & $0.015$ \\ \hline
  206. $6.0 - 8.0$ & $0.015$ & $0.017$ & $0.021$ & $0.018$ & $0.011$ & $0.016$ & $0.018$ & $0.015$ \\ \hline
  207. $15.0 - 17.0$ & $0.015$ & $0.022$ & $0.025$ & $0.018$ & $0.017$ & $0.014$ & $0.021$ & $0.018$ \\ \hline
  208. $17.0 - 19.0$ & $0.018$ & $0.026$ & $0.030$ & $0.022$ & $0.021$ & $0.018$ & $0.025$ & $0.024$ \\ \hline
  209. \end{tabular}
  210. \end{tiny}
  211. }
  212.  
  213. \end{frame}
  214.  
  215.  
  216. \begin{frame}\frametitle{Expected differences, MoM vs fit}
  217.  
  218.  
  219. \begin{tiny}
  220. \begin{tabular}{ |c |c | c | c| c| c| c| c|c|}
  221. \hline
  222. {~} & \multicolumn{8}{|c|}{ observed difference in terms of sigmas} \\ \hline
  223. $q^2 [GeV^2 /c^4]$ & $F_l$ & $S_3$ & $S_4$ & $S_5$ & $S_6$ & $S_7$ & $S_8$ & $S_9$ \\ \hline
  224. $0.1 - 0.98$ & $-0.618$ & $-0.827$ & $-0.074$ & $0.794$ & $0.447$ & $-0.807$ & $0.581$ & $0.2374$ \\ \hline
  225. $1.1 - 2.5$ & $-0.624$ & $-1.687$ & $-0.518$ & $-1.4854$ & $0.932$ & $1.334$ & $0.5260$ & $-0.632$ \\ \hline
  226. $2.5 - 4.0$ & $-0.106$ & $-0.842$ & $0.240$ & $0.0223$ & $0.935$ & $-0.174$ & $-0.296$ & $1.098$ \\ \hline
  227. $4.0 - 6.0$ & $-2.063$ & $-0.1230$ & $-0.105$ & $1.0441$ & $-0.583$ & $-0.129$ & $2.394$ & $-1.921$ \\ \hline
  228. $6.0 - 8.0$ & $-1.1236$ & $0.5489$ & $-0.4824$ & $2.001$ & $-0.628$ & $0.059$ & $0.800$ & $-2.329$ \\ \hline
  229. $15.0 - 17.0$ & $ 0.1852$ & $0.128$ & $-0.560$ & $-0.230$ & $-0.573$ & $-0.572$ & $0.411$ & $0.062$ \\ \hline
  230. $17.0 - 19.0$ & $-0.859$ & $-1.215$ & $1.148$ & $0.757$ & $0.105$ & $-0.0927$ & $-0.529$ & $-0.304$ \\ \hline
  231. \end{tabular}
  232. \end{tiny}
  233.  
  234.  
  235. \end{frame}
  236.  
  237.  
  238.  
  239. \end{document}